Loftslagsnefnd Sameinuu janna, IPCC, veri stokku upp...

ipcc.gif

Niurstaa aljlegs fagrs vsindamanna sem fali var a leggja mat strf Aljaloftslagsnefndar Sޠ(IPCC) er s a gera urfi rttkar breytingar starfsemi hennar. Leggur ri jafnframt til a formaur nefndarinnar geti ekki seti jafn lengi og undir nverandi fyrirkomulagi.

En nverandi formaur nefndarinnar, Dr Rajendra Pachauri, situr tv sex ra kjrtmabil.

leggur ri, sem ensku nefnist Inter-Academy Council (IAC), til a skipu veri framkvmdastjrn semhir ailar, jafnvel ailar sem ekki starfa vsindasamflaginu, hafi agang a, v skyni a auka trverugleika nefndarinnar.

a er jafnframt skoun rsins a Aljaloftslagsnefndin hafi brugist seint og illa vi uppljstrunum um rangfrslur skrslu nefndarinnar rinu 2007.

Ber ar hst s sp a ri 2035 veri jklar Himalaja-fjallgarsins horfnir me llu og agengi um 800 milljna manna a drykkjarvatni ar me gna, sp sem hefur n veri hrakin me llu.

etta mtti lesa frtt Morgunblasins. raun er etta strfrtt hn lti lti yfir sr.

Ekki verur fjalla um skrslu fagrs vsindamannanna hr, heldur lti ngja a vsa hana.

Sj vefsu fagrsins hr, en grarlegt lag hefur veri suna og v vefjnninn hruni anna slagi:

http://reviewipcc.interacademycouncil.net

ar m finna skrsluna. Liggi vefsan niri vegna lags m skja rdrtt r greinarger vsindarsins og alla skrsluna hr:

Executive Summary
Full Report

Hr m sj hverjir sitja vsindarinu.

pacahauri_and_his_novel.jpg

Formaur IPCC heldur hr skldsgu sem hann hefur gefi t.

--- --- ---

Nokkur ummli um niurstu Inter Academy Council (IAC):

The Telegraph:
Climate change predictions must be based on evidence, report on IPCC says

BBC:
Stricter controls urged for the UN's climate body

The New York Times:
Review Finds Flaws in U.N. Climate Panel Structure

New Scientist:
Climate panel must 'fundamentally reform' to survive

Dr. Roy Spencer loftslagsfringur:
Dump the IPCC Process, It Cannot Be Fixed

Real Climate:
IPCC report card


mbl.is Loftslagsnefndin veri stokku upp
Tilkynna um vieigandi tengingu vi frtt
Skrr tengdar essari bloggfrslu:

Sasta frsla | Nsta frsla

Athugasemdir

1 Smmynd: Ragnhildur Kolka

Fyllilega tmabr kvrun.

Ragnhildur Kolka, 30.8.2010 kl. 20:36

2 Smmynd: Gunnar Th. Gunnarsson

Dr. Pachauri er glpamaur og dlti merkilegt a IPCC skuli hafa vali hann sem formann sinn.... mann sem hefur fjrhagslegra hagsmuna a gta a halda lofti kjufrttum og spm um loftslagsv.

Robert Marshall, ingmaur Samfylkingarinnar og "umhverfisverndarsinni", hefur tt vafasmum viskiptum vi Dr. Panchauri.

Gunnar Th. Gunnarsson, 31.8.2010 kl. 09:36

3 Smmynd: gst H Bjarnason

Gunnar. g vil n ekki taka undir au or n a hann s glpamaur. g held samt a a hefi veri hgt a finna heppilegri mann embtti.

gst H Bjarnason, 31.8.2010 kl. 12:15

4 Smmynd: Sveinn Atli Gunnarsson

g tel ekki a essi skrsla nefndarinnar hafi veri srstaklega til hfus Pachauri (hvaa persnulegu skoanir sem flk hefur honum), heldur hluti elilegrar runnar, sem hugsanlega hefur veri tt af sta af gagnrni (bi rttmtri og rttmtri) sambandi vi einstk ml sem upp hafa komi. vef New Scientist m lesa um etta ml, ar stendur m.a.:

Shapiro told reporters: "An organisation like the IPCC needs to have its leadership constantly changed" to maintain its "overall virility". He said that the suggested changes "were not motivated by or connected with Dr Pachauri or any other leader".

Sveinn Atli Gunnarsson, 31.8.2010 kl. 12:41

5 Smmynd: gst H Bjarnason

g tek undir a sem Svatli segir, .e. a skrsla nefndarinnar beinist ekki srstakelga a Pacauri. Hugsanlega frekar a innra skipulagi og vinnubrgum stofnunarinnar.

Governance and Management, Review Process, Characterizing and Communicating Uncertainity, Communications og Transparency eru helstu atriin sem fjalla er um.

Skrslan sjlf er mjg lng og tarleg, en til a f hugmynd um efni hennar er etv. ng a lesa Executive Summary. ar koma aalatriin og rlegginagar skrsluhfunda fram.

gst H Bjarnason, 31.8.2010 kl. 12:58

6 Smmynd: Hskuldur Bi Jnsson

Mr skilst a ein rleggingin s s a vinnuhpur 2 birti sna skrslu seinna en vinnuhpur 1 og vinni annig r eim ggnum sem s vinnuhpur hefur sett saman.

Eins og komi hefur ljs hefur flest staist tmans tnn sem kom fr vinnuhpi 1 (vanmat sjvarstubreytinga helsti vankantinn) og v hefi vinnuhpur 2 sjlfsagt ekki gert fyrrnefnd mistk ef hann hefi t.d. haft agang a ggnum fr vinnuhpi 1 (varandi jkla Himalaya).

Sj t.d. frslu fr v febrar af loftslag.is (Heit mlefni).

Gunnar: Hvaa glpi ertu a tala um hj Pachauri, fylgistu ekkert me frttum?

Sj Rajendra Pachauri cleared of financial misdealings

Hskuldur Bi Jnsson, 31.8.2010 kl. 13:29

7 Smmynd: gst H Bjarnason

g hef aeins lesi rdrtt skrslunnar og glugga stra skjali. g held a flestallir geti veri sammla um a a sem ar kemur fram s skynsamlegt og veri mjg ganglegt fyrir IPCC veri a teki til greina. Mr snist skrslan vera hgvr og skrifu af skynsemi og yfirvegun.

---

Til frleiks afrita g hr fyrir nean umsgn ltillar stofnunar sem hefur veri frekar gagnrnin starfssemi IPCC. Mr snist a eim ltist vel tillgurnar sem koma fram skrslu IAC.

GWPF Calls On IPCC To Implement Fundamental Reforms Without Delay

The Global Warming Policy Foundation, 30 August 2010

TheGlobal Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) broadly welcomes the recommendations by theInterAcademy Council (IAC) for fundamental reforms of the IPCC and its management structure.

This report is highly critical of the IPCC in a number of key respects. The GWPF has been critical of the IPCC on a number of occasions since our foundation last November, and published several critical papers and submissions. This Report shows our critique to be well founded.

The GWPF calls upon the IPCC to accept the key recommendations and implement them without delay. Otherwise there can be no confidence in the outcome of the current Fifth Assessment Report which is expected to be finalised by 2014, Lord Lawson said.

The GWPF welcomes the IAC’s recommendation that the chairmanship of the IPCC should be limited to the term of one assessment. "I interpret this recommendation as an indirect call on Dr Pachauri to step down. After all, he has already been presiding over one assessment," Dr Benny Peiser, the director of the GWPF said.

We also support the IAC’s recommendation that future IPCC chairmen should have formal qualifications as well as undergone rigorous conflict-of-interest assessments.

The IAC has produced a fair-minded assessment of the IPCC, a welcome change to recent inquires into the Climategate affair which look manifestly imbalanced and unprofessional in comparison.

We welcome the IAC's recommendation that "review editors should ensure that genuine controversies are reflected in the report and be satisfied that due consideration was given to properly documented alternative views. Lead authors should explicitly document that the full range of thoughtful scientific views has been considered."

We welcome the IAC recommendation that "Lead Authors should explicitly document that a range of scientific viewpoints has been considered, and Coordinating Lead Authors and Review Editors should satisfy themselves that due consideration was given to properly documented alternative views.”

The IAC report states: “Equally important is combating confirmation bias‹the tendency of authors to place too much weight on their own views relative to other views. As pointed out to the Committee by a presenter and some questionnaire respondents, alternative views are not always cited in a chapter if the Lead Authors do not agree with them.” In other words, the report says they were biased.

The IAC report states: “Interviews and responses to the Committee’s questionnaire revealed a lack of transparency in several stages of the IPCC assessment process, including scoping and the selection of authors and reviewers, as well as in the selection of scientific and technical information considered in the chapters.”

We welcome the recommendations that the IPCC “should establish a formal set of criteria and processes for selecting Coordinating Lead Authors and Lead Authors. Lead Authors should explicitly document that a range of scientific viewpoints has been considered, and Coordinating Lead Authors and Review Editors should satisfy themselves that due consideration was given to properly documented alternative views.”

From these recommendations we conclude that IPCC has been narrow minded and did not take into account any other views than the 'mainstream' and that lead authors ignored views that did not tally with their own. It is time that the IPCC now undergoes fundamental reforms.

gst H Bjarnason, 1.9.2010 kl. 07:40

8 identicon

g er smu skoun og R. Spencer a a s rtt a loka IPCC allavega nverandi mynd, vegna ess a stofnskr nefndarinnar var fr upphafi bilu a mnu liti. Samkvmt stofnskr st aldrei til a hn fjallai um neitt nema hvort og hve mikil hrif Koldoxi gti hugsanlega haft loftslag/veurfar jarar og hvaa tt , og fingargjf fkk hn svo undir rs a aeins ein tegund af niurstu var viunandi, enda ekki nein rf fyrir loftslagsnefnfnd ef anna vri uppi teningnum.

Annars orar Jeff Id Bloggsunni "the Air Vent", formla sem hann skrifar vi endurpstun grein Spencers um sama efni etta kannski betur en g. Hann virist allavega hafa svipa lit IPCC og g , tengill hr a nean

tAV um Grein Dr. Spencer's

Bjssi (IP-tala skr) 2.9.2010 kl. 22:41

Bta vi athugasemd

Ekki er lengur hgt a skrifa athugasemdir vi frsluna, ar sem tmamrk athugasemdir eru liin.

Höfundur

Ágúst H Bjarnason
Ágúst H Bjarnason

Verkfr. hjá Verkís.
agbjarn-hjá-gmail.com

Audiatur et altera pars

Aðeins málefnalegar athugasemdir, sem eiga ótvíætt við efni viðkomandi pistils, og skrifaðar án skætings og neikvæðni í garð annarra, og að jafnaði undir fullu nafni, verða birtar. 

Um bloggi

Ginnungagap

mislegt

Loftslag

Click to get your own widget

Teljari

free counters

lver

http://metalprices.com/PubCharts/PublicCharts.aspx?metal=al&type=L&weight=t&days=12&size=M&bg=&cs=1011&cid=0

Slin dag:

(Smella mynd)

.

Vinnan mn:

Oluveri dag:

Heimsknir

Flettingar

  • dag (17.5.): 9
  • Sl. slarhring: 14
  • Sl. viku: 105
  • Fr upphafi: 749532

Anna

  • Innlit dag: 4
  • Innlit sl. viku: 56
  • Gestir dag: 4
  • IP-tlur dag: 4

Uppfrt 3 mn. fresti.
Skringar

Ma 2022
S M M F F L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31        

Innskrning

Ath. Vinsamlegast kveiki Javascript til a hefja innskrningu.

Hafu samband